| I was forced to acknowledge too late, much too late, that I too had loved, that I was capable of suffering, and that I was human after all. |
How can someone so far removed from humanity—cut off from human connection—still feel the same fears, longings, love, and quiet ache that define being human? Is it something written into us? Are there emotions so innate that they survive even isolation, even the absence of touch, memory, and shared life?
I Who Have Never Known Men begins with a haunting premise. The narrator is one of forty women locked inside an underground cell. None of them know why they are there, who imprisoned them, or what exists beyond the walls. The only thing that sets the narrator apart is memory. The other women remember a life before captivity. She does not. This prison is the only world she has ever known.
The women spend their days talking about what came before—homes, relationships, routines, freedoms. When the narrator tries to join in, she is gently but firmly shut out. Why include someone who cannot relate? Why explain a world she has never seen? So she learns to stay quiet. To observe. To imagine. In the absence of experience, she builds an inner world of her own.
What stayed with me most is that despite having no real human life to draw from, the narrator still feels everything. Teenage angst. Curiosity. Desire. Even innocent fantasies—like imagining the guard who watches over them from outside the cell. No one ever teaches her what love or longing is supposed to look like, yet she feels them anyway.
This book is not interested in explaining where they are, how they got there, or why they are imprisoned. That absence feels intentional. Instead, it asks something quieter and far more unsettling: how do humans remain human in inhumane circumstances? How do emotions survive when connection is denied?
Then one day, a siren blares. The guards flee in panic, leaving the keys behind. After sixteen years, the door is finally open. But freedom is not taken easily. The women hesitate. They argue. They are afraid of what lies beyond the bunker, afraid of a world they no longer recognize—or one that may not exist at all. When they finally step outside, it is slowly, cautiously, carrying their fear with them.
Sometimes, I used to sit under the sky, on a clear night, and gaze at the stars, saying, in my croaky voice: “Lord, if you’re up there somewhere, and you aren’t too busy, come and say a few words to me, because I’m very lonely and it would make me so happy.” Nothing happened. So I reckon that humanity— which I wonder whether I belong to —really had a very vivid imagination.
The novel is often labeled dystopian, but that word feels insufficient. This isn’t a story about a broken world as much as it is about endurance. About how deeply human emotions run. About how longing, fear, hope, and connection exist even in silence, even in confinement.
At its core, this is a quiet and unsettling book—one that lingers. It reminded me that feeling is not something we are taught. It is something we carry.
This is not a book you read for answers. It’s one you read to remember what remains of us when everything else is taken away.

.jpg)


.jpg)
.jpg)




